An Amish Veteran of the Revolutionary War and the War of 1812

Not all Mennonites or Amish in Pennsylvania maintained neutrality during the Revolutionary War. Herman Hostetter, the grandson of Amish bishop Jacob Hostetter of Manor Township in Lancaster County, joined the Bucks County Volunteers, and linked with General William Howe’s British forces in Philadelphia in 1778. It has been suggested this was in response to General Howe’s offer of 50 acres of land to any able-bodied men who were willing to join in the King’s army.

Shortly thereafter, Howe withdrew from Philadelphia, and Hostetter was among the first evacuees to Port Roseway, Nova Scotia (now called Shelburne), where he purchased a farm among other loyalists. In 1780 (at the earliest), in Nova Scotia, he married Ann Newman Kennedy, the daughter of an Irish loyalist, John Kennedy, who had made only a short stop in Canada before returning to Ireland. Herman and Ann’s first child was born in 1783.

Hostetter Cemetery

Herman Hostetter’s burial location at Port Weller, Ontario. Google map.

Hostetler was by then a member of the Anglican Church. By 1793 Hostetter moved to Upper Canada on the Niagara Peninsula and brought his family a year or two later. He owned property in several places, but lived in Grantham Township at the end of his life. He died in December 1812 from an illness he contracted at age fifty-nine during service as a private with the First Regiment of the Lincoln Militia. He likely participated in the Battle of Queenston Heights in the War of 1812, in which general Isaac Brock was killed. Hostetter had been a leader in the Anglican Church located in what became the city of St. Catharines, though many of his grandchildren became Methodists and Baptists.

Some of the information about Herman Hostetter is not consistent. The Hamilton branch of the United Empire Loyalist Association of Canada in an article on its website by Ken Simmons provides earlier dates for immigration to Canada and marriage to Ann Kennedy than those proposed by Hostetter’s biographer, Brian K. Narhi in Hostetter, U.E.L.: Origins and History of an Ontario Family. (St. Catharines, ON: Ganymede Press, 1992). Some accounts of Herman Hostetter link him to a different parent. I have generally followed Narhi.

If you wish to know more about Amish and Mennonites and the Revolutionary War, read In Search of Promised Lands.

If you wish to comment on this blog, click on the button above.

The War of 1812 finds the Mennonites

After 1793 Quakers, Mennonites and Tunkers (Brethren in Christ) in Upper Canada could avoid militia service if they were willing to pay an annual fine. This was similar to arrangements that existed in the United States.

Waor 1812 Plaque at The First Mennonite Church (Vineland)

Jonathan Seiling, who has done extensive research on the War of 1812,  with a plaque commemorating the Ontario Mennonite response to the War of 1812. Located at The First Mennonite Church (Vineland). Courtesy Jonathan Seiling.

Within 20 years of this understanding, Upper Canadian Mennonites faced their first challenge in relation to war.  That was a ongoing conflict between the United States and Great Britain that resulted in the War of 1812. Prior to the war, concern about the impending conflict led Upper Canadian Mennonites to take several steps.  In 1810 they petitioned the government to recognize their unbaptized sons under the age of 21 as also exempt from militia service. This petition was accepted. In 1811 they reprinted an English translation of the Dordrecht Confession of Faith in Niagara-on-the-Lake. This was done to better inform their government and their neighbors of their long heritage as a peace church.

For Mennonites in the Waterloo and Markham areas the war, when it came, was not terribly onerous. They paid their fines to avoid militia service, and they allowed their horses and wagons to used by the military to transport goods, sometimes with their sons as drivers. Although there were some scary incidents, these Mennonites prospered as they received top dollar for the products their farms produced. The scariest incident took place in the fall of 1813 when a large number of young men from the Grand River settlement were pressed into service to assist Major General Procter in his retreat from Detroit in September. The British forces were overtaken and scattered by a larger American force in the Battle of the Thames (near present-day Chatham). In the chaos of retreat the Mennonite young men were ordered to flee as they could. They mostly abandoned their horses and wagons, but were successful in personal escape, except for Adam Shupe (1793–1878), who was briefly captured before being released by General William Henry Harrison. Twenty Mennonite and Tunker farmers made claims for the losses of wagons, horses, and other materials experienced in that retreat

Niagara River in 1810

The Niagara Riv er in 1810 . Mennonites lived along the river between the Chippewa River (left hand side of map) and Black Creek (creek immediately to the right of “Proposed Road” text). Courtesy Brock University Map Library.

The story was more serious on the Niagara Peninsula, where a significant number of Mennonites were caught between the two sides. Christian Zavitz, the owner of the mill at Port Colborne saw his cargo boat seized for military purposes within weeks of the war’s beginning. Later in 1812 he was forced to house and feed about a hundred men of the Norfolk Militia in his house and outbuildings. At the end of 1814 his property was looted by American raiders, though one of the raiders was fatally wounded by Canadian militia men guarding his mill.

Suffering similar losses were nine Mennonite families who lived right on the Niagara River between Niagara Falls and Fort Erie. Their properties were overrun by soldiers from both sides during the war, and their buildings and food were frequently requisitioned for both American and British militia use. One such family was that of Ulrich and Magdalena Miller Strickler. Ulrich built a stone house and generally prospered as a farmer on his 210 acres. However, at different times during the war his home was occupied by both American and British forces. In 1815 he made claims for losses of produce and goods taken by the American troops in the summer of 1814 and those taken by the British troops later that same year after the Americans had retreated. The list of losses caused by the British included “Rent for 4 weeks for the House” which was used for a commissary and “Rent for the Barn” used for barracks. The request for rent for the two buildings was listed at 110 York pounds. Magdalena’s brother, John,  submitted claims for twenty gallons of whiskey taken by the British in November 1812; horses, grain, and a rifle taken by the Americans in 1813 and 1814; five buildings damaged by the Americans in 1814; and a large quantity of food supplied to the British army.

A few Mennonite young men did serve in the militia because they were over the age of 21 and had not yet joined the church. One such was Henry W. Wanner, who at age 24 was unbaptized at the time of the war, and thus was not exempted from militia duty. He was reported to have served in one of the skirmishes with American troops in the Niagara area, but either refused to fire a shot or shot into the air in order to avoid injuring anyone. He then became ill with “camp fever” (typhus) and was allowed to return home.

To learn more about the War of 1812 and the Mennonites read In Search of Promised Lands.

If you would like to comment on this article, click on the button above.